Tilton poured his budget to buy television time into these communities he targeted. In the complaint,sixmen have come forward with the allegations saying they were brought to theUSin 2018 and were made to worklong hours often under dangerous conditions. This construct of law by White people is what creates and perpetuates White Supremacy as defined by CRT. The groups expenditures show how it effectively acted as Murphys reelection campaign arm even before the governor announced he would seek reelection to a second term. The incident took place at Shri Omkarnath Temple in the Brazos Valley, Texas on January 11, KBTX-TV reported on Friday. Robert Tilton and his ministry were investigated by the IRS but was never charged with anything. The US Governments indifferent and laissez-faire approach to the intrinsic religious racism in America was challenged in the 1982 court case Bob Jones University v. The United States. This happened when Scientology recruited her mother in Siberia. Daniel Werner, a lawyer in the wage claim suit, said he believed this could be the first forced-labor case of its scale in the United States since dozens of Thai garment workers were discovered laboring in horrible conditions in El Monte, Calif. in 1995 a landmark case that helped lead to the creation of the federal Trafficking Victims Protection Act. Owning an arsenal in America is not illegal because the Second Amendment says it is legal. Tony Ortega, Recruit poor people with false promises of a better life in America, Bring them into America using R1 religious worker visas, The use of religious worker visas acts to conceal human trafficking and exploitation, Do not allow them to talk to their family back home, Ensure that exploited workers only get a minimum amount of sleep, Demand enormous amounts of labor from the trafficked workers, Make these workers fear arrest and imprisonment if they try to escape, Call this forced labor and exploitation religious work, Pay the workers slave wages and justify it because they are religious volunteers. We said, We dont want to die like that, he said. Chidiac did not immediately return messages. One of the lawyers in the wage claim suit has said this could be the first forced labour casein the USsince 1995. NEW JERSEY COLLEGES TO HIRE 223 FOOTBALL COACHES New Jersey colleges will get $895M from American Rescue Plan, by POLITICOs Carly Sitrin: New Jerseys colleges and universities are set to get more than $895 million from the latest pot of coronavirus rescue funds from the federal government. This is how the First Amendment works. The workers, who lived in trailers hidden from view, had been promised jobs helping to build the temple in rural Robbinsville, N.J., with standard work hours and ample time off, according to the lawsuit, a wage claim filed in U.S. District Court in New Jersey. The FBI has also raided the building, from which they removed about 90 workers who were allegedly paid less than $1 USD per hour. Our response to the well-publicized incident involving a Neptune Board of Education staff member has been swift and serious but cannot be made public, Crader wrote online Thursday. They arrived in the wake of a civil lawsuit filed against the massive Hindu temple that alleges labor and immigration law violations. FBI agents raided a Robbinsville, New Jersey, Hindu temple over allegations of forced labor. The lawsuit says more than 200 workers - many who don't speak or understand English - were coerced into signing employment agreements to work at the Hindu temple, had their passports [] Without having gotten into the lawsuit much, my initial impression is that if they did any masonry/cement (as opposed to just manual labor) theyre going to have major Joy-zee problem. The ministry keeps the money they donated and is under no legal obligation to return the money. ***** The largest Hindu temple in North America is reported to be the massive Swaminarayan Akshardham, located in Robbinsville, New Jersey. A Hindu temple in the US state of Texas has been raided by burglars who stole some of the valuables from the premises, leaving the Indian community in a state of shock, according to a media report. They were paid $50 in cash, with the rest deposited in accounts in India, the complaint said. 3,664,496 fully vaccinated, or about 39.4 percent of the population. The Mormon treasure horde is only known about due to a whistleblower. The lawsuit said the mens passports had been confiscated, and they were confined to the fenced-in and guarded site, where they were forbidden from talking to visitors and religious volunteers. This racist ban was not illegal in any way whatsoever nor could the matter be heard before any secular court. But it was contained to 50 health care workers and 31 adult patients at the facility, none of whom developed serious illness or was hospitalized, he said., How the closed pipeline and truck driver shortages could affect N.J. gas pumps, R.I.P. The Hindu Temple of Dayton is a Hindu temple in Beavercreek, Ohio. Even more is the fact that authorities would gladly go after the Hindus while leaving scientology to do the same if not worse. But in the first seven days of May, only 121,000 first doses of Pfizer and Moderna were administered, according to a review of state data. #FBIRaidsOnHinduTemple #ShriSwaminarayanMandir #NewJersey #ABPNewsLive #ABPSanjha #ABPNews ' Hindu Temple ' FBI | BAPS | News Jersey | ABP S. First Amendment religious protections and Supreme Court rulings were used to enforce slavery and racism in America for hundreds of years. Find out who's up, who's down, and who really has the presidents ear in our West Wing Playbook newsletter, the insider's guide to the Biden White House and Cabinet. United States v. Thind (1923) Scientology promises a generous wage and a better life in America. Feds raid New Jersey BAPS temple, face forced labor chargesFederal authorities in New Jersey are accusing the highly influential Hindu organization BAPS of h. IMO, generalizing the abuse of the system actually gives undeserved credence to a pseudo-religion such as scientology. Details of the groups spending has not been previously reported. The New Jersey case, Mr. Werner said, could be compared to instances of severe worker exploitation seen overseas. The PMgaveaeulogy at his funeral. In fact, I would argue that as the US increasingly secularizes so do the hucksters. No one seemed put out by the dopey white folk. However,they were paid merely 10per centof the hourly minimum wage according to New Jersey law, and forced to live ingruellingconditions. First Amendment religious rights and Second Amendment gun ownership rights exist simultaneously. As of 2021, only 2% of Utah is Black. Mr. Kumar, who is named in the federal lawsuit, said in an interview with The New York Times that BAPSs response to the illness and death of his co-worker prompted him and others to come forward. Along with its temples, BAPS publicizes its good works. Phil Murphys closest allies spent nearly $13.2 million during most of his first term to boost the Democrats agenda. The problem is not the system but unscrupulous bad actors. 7. It builds temples around the world that draw visitors with awe-inspiring white stone spires, intricate carvings, gurgling fountains and wandering peacocks. Scientology is particularly notorious in this regard. FOR CLEAN VERSION SEE STORY NUMBER: 4325293. Religious workers in America are exempt from secular workplace protections as they are classed as volunteers and not employees. It seems to me that hucksterism is a phenomenon that stretches across the religious and secular realms alike. Besides the FBI, at least two other federal departments, the Department of Homeland Security and the Department of Labor, were involved in the action, which reportedly linked to claims of labor and immigration law violations, the New York Times reported. We are not alone in arguing that here is a pervasive and widespread abuse of the First Amendment religious protections. The complaint filed on Tuesday named six men who said they were among more than 200 Indian nationals who were recruited to come to the United States starting about 2018 and were made to work grueling hours under often dangerous conditions on the New Jersey site. Believers feel these intangibles confer a benefit upon them and so they donate money and deduct that donation from their income tax. There are parallels in other places. Id imagine that theyve closed the temple to the public and have goon guards around the entrance. The total amounts range from $65,523 for the New Brunswick Theological Seminary to nearly $148 million for Rutgers University. The Second Amendment gives Americans the right to own as many assault weapons as they can afford. Of course, Scientology has had its internal culture of violence and cover up exposed many times. ***** FBI agents swarmed the site and tonight an attorney is calling the labor lawsuit against them one of the largest in decades.Tune into the @cwphilly at 10 and @CBSPhilly at 11 pic.twitter.com/62V95pNA21. GPB Capital Holdings: Court-Appointed Monitors Report on Q4 2022 Activities. Religions have increasingly turned to using secular arbitration law in contracts signed by religious volunteers. It says such R-1 visas are religious visas available to "those who minister or work in religious vocations or occupations" and are members of the religious denomination sponsoring the visa holders. The IRS maintained that racist groups did not qualify for religious tax exemption. New Direction New Jersey, which is organized under Section 501(c)(4) of the federal tax code, quietly disclosed all of its donations and spending to the state Election Law Enforcement Commission in February. I would also argue that grifters are by no means a specifically religious phenomenon. We're going to have to scrap to get there, almost certainly, Murphy said of his goal at a briefing Monday., LD37 Dierdre Paul insulted and hurt, by InsiderNJs John Van Vilet: Paul has accused Assemblyman Gordon Johnson of inappropriate sexual conduct in 2008 A recent communique from Paul to Huttle through social media, however, exposed the intensely personal nature of their feud. Eyewitness News. According to the complaint, the workers wereallegedlybrought to the US on R-1 Visas that are applicable for clergy and religious workers like missionaries. In a surprise to some, these funds cant be used for debt payments, a potential complication for fiscally stressed governments that had already etched out plans to pay off loans The rule could also affect New Jersey, which sold nearly $3.7 billion of bonds last year to cover its shortfall during the pandemic. Learn how your comment data is processed. Hicks also defended his departments soaring overtime costs before the Senate Budget and Appropriations Committee, OFFICIALS STRUGGLE TO INTRODUCE NEW JERSEYANS TO NOVEL CONCEPT OF BRIBERY With NJ COVID vaccine goal at risk, 'bribe people' an option to get more shots in arms, by The Records Scott Fallon and Kristie Kattafi: New Jersey's daily rate of COVID vaccinations has plummeted so much in recent weeks that it's casting doubt on whether Gov. You further agree to our privacy policy and terms of service. Around 7 minutes long, the footage features an up close look at art and architectural details - it is undeniably mesmerizing. wont support eminent domain, wants to negotiate BMC deal with HRH, Former Newark Archbishop sexually abused 5-year-old in church rectory, lawsuit claims, Swift action kept outbreak of COVID variant in NJ facility from spreading into community, How the closed pipeline and truck driver shortages could affect N.J. gas pumps, N.J.s famous Delaware River hot dog man, Greg Crance, dead at 56 from COVID, View all our political and policy newsletters, View the Full New Jersey Playbook Archives . Nope. N.J.s famous Delaware River hot dog man, Greg Crance, dead at 56 from COVID, Please make sure that the email address you typed in is valid, Pro-Murphy group details $13.2M in spending, Senate Republicans spar with Persichilli over pandemic response, N.J. still months away from getting body cameras to all officers at troubled womens prison, top official says, With NJ COVID vaccine goal at risk, 'bribe people' an option to get more shots in arms, Assembly panel to weigh bill allowing 17-year-olds to vote in primaries Wednesday, NJ asks Facebook to abandon harmful tween version of Instagram, How historic judge shortage could overwhelm states judicial system, NJ considers $10M to manage lakes, including algal bloom fight, For buzzy nuggets and details that you won't find anywhere else, subscribe today, Treasury rescue wont bail out Chicago, New Jersey from debt, New Jersey colleges will get $895M from American Rescue Plan, The N.J. men accused of assaulting Capitol Officer Brian Sicknick will remain in custody until trial, States won't get Johnson & Johnson vaccines next week, Camden-backed Democrats win by wide margin in Collingswood, Foodborne illness sickens 60% of N.J. districts teachers after school luncheon, A Camden question for mayoral candidate Victor Carstarphen, 'Action' taken against Neptune vice principal involved in transphobic rant, Jersey City BOE approves fully funded $814M budget at uncharacteristically brief meeting, Beach excess: Jersey City Mayor Steve Fulop puts his foot in it again. The Huttle campaign attacked Johnson in more than one statement, while not specifically mentioning Paul in those exact statements, but referring to the incident in some detail and demanding the assemblyman 'come clean. The Homeland Security Investigations division of Immigration and Customs Enforcement declined to comment. Robert Tilton existed and got rich because the system allowed him to do exactly what he did. A spokeswoman for the F.B.I. Passports were confiscated, and workers were confined to the guarded compound, the suit alleges. They were given $450 a month $50 in hand and $400 deposited to their bank accounts in India. A massive Hindu temple in New Jersey brought some 200 workers from India to the US on R-1 visas as religious volunteers, but forced them to work on illegally low wages, a class action. still months away from getting body cameras to all officers at troubled womens prison, top official says, by NJ Advance Medias Blake Nelson: All officers at New Jerseys only womens prison should have body cameras by the fall, Corrections Commissioner Marcus Hicks said Tuesday during his first public appearance before state senators since those lawmakers voted overwhelmingly for his ouster. The evidence is all there. Too rich? Swaminarayan temple in US raided, workers taken from India treated as forced Somnath, Akshardham & now Ram Mandir Gujarat family designing temples for 15 generations. By signing up you agree to allow POLITICO to collect your user information and use it to better recommend content to you, send you email newsletters or updates from POLITICO, and share insights based on aggregated user information. A few examples illustrate this point: The stunningly beautiful Swaminarayan Akshardham Hindu temple in Robbinsville, New Jersey the largest Hindu temple in the US was raided this week by the authorities. Across the road is a worship center for the Sikh community. None of this is religious work; it is all manual labor for pennies an hour. This is some damn good writing, Jeff . But what happens when First Amendment religious protections and Second Amendment gun protections collide with the Government wanting to impose a terrorist definition on a religious group? A prominent Hindu sect that operates a New Jersey temple raided by federal authorities earlier this year is facing new accusations that it forced hundreds of low-caste workers to labor. Even though he was an immoral and greedy charlatan, the First Amendment gave him permission to do everything he did. The New York Times: The workers, who lived in trailers hidden from view, had been promised jobs helping to build the temple in rural Robbinsville, N.J., with standard work hours and ample time off, according to the lawsuit, a wage claim filed in U.S. District Court in New Jersey. Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email along with 7129 other subscribers. The way he moved from Neo-Nazi KKK Grand Wizard to a born again Christian rooted in the racist Christian Identity movement was pure semantics on his part. Kanu Patel, the chief executive of BAPS, who is named as a defendant, told The New York Times, "I respectfully disagree with the wage claim." ", CLOSE CALL Swift action kept outbreak of COVID variant in NJ facility from spreading into community, by The Records Lindy Washburn: The Hackensack Meridian Health system squelched an outbreak of COVID-19 late last year that infected 81 staff and patients at the Carrier Clinic, a behavioral health facility it owns in Somerset County and prevented the virus from spreading further. A Hindu temple in the US state of Texas has been raided by burglars who stole some of the valuables from the premises, leaving the Indian community in a state of shock, according to a media. [citation needed] BAPS has beenbehind scores of temples built around the world. Hindu Temple Listings ISKCON of Central New Jersey 1020 W 7th St, Plainfield, Plainfield , New Jersey 7063 Hindu Temple. The temple has previously come to the attention of authorities. They were brought to the United States on religious visas, or R-1 visas temporary visas used for clergy and lay religious workers such as missionaries and presented to the U.S. government as volunteers, according to the claim. Lawyers for the men, however, said they did manual labor on the site, working nearly 13 hours a day lifting large stones, operating cranes and other heavy machinery, building roads and storm sewers, digging ditches and shoveling snow, all for the equivalent of about $450 per month. At least three federal agencies the F.B.I., the Department of Homeland Security and the Department of Labor were involved in the action early Tuesday, which was said to be connected to the claims of labor and immigration law violations, according to three people familiar with the matter. Instead Fulop had his spokesman blame the media for reporting his foolishness [Wetsuit wholesaler] Conrad Ferla cut to the heart of the matter. ***** After fleeing and a manhunt, Warren Jeffs was arrested in 2006 and later convicted for his sex crimes against the young girls in the FLDS community. A Sea Org recruiting piece shows why Scientology needs a slave labor pool of ~2,000 people to run its series of hotels and other operations in Clearwater. So, Jeffrey, whats your take on why the Church of Scientology doesnt get raided? It opened in 1984, making it the oldest Hindu temple in the Dayton metropolitan area. If you study religious litigation in America, the same type of lawsuits are filed over and over and the courts almost always refuse to interfere. NEW JERSEY (Diya TV) Federal authorities in New Jersey are accusing the highly influential Hindu organization BAPS of human trafficking and wage violations. DOWNLOAD FOR iOS DOWNLOAD FOR ANDROID. Why is this even allowed? India needs fair, non-hyphenated and questioning journalism, packed with on-ground reporting. Enlightenment does not turn a blind eye to suffering. We are naturally shaken by this turn of events and are sure that once the full facts come out, we will be able to provide answers and show that these accusations and allegations are without merit, Mr. Joshi said. Crader cited legal restrictions barring the disclosure of any discipline, but made plain the district did not look the other way. 3. You are like whitewashed tombs, which look beautiful on the outside but on the inside are full of the bones of the dead and everything unclean. May this be a wedge in the ongoing work to stop slave labor in religious settings. But the compensation board offered her a settlement $5,000. Karan Deep Singh contributed reporting from New Delhi. They were asked to sign several documents, often in English, and instructed to tell U.S. embassy staffers that they were skilled carvers or decorative painters, the complaint said. The lawsuit, filed Tuesday in federal court, accuses Bochasanwasi Akshar Purushottam Swaminarayan Sanstha, a Hindu sect known as BAPS, and its leaders of "shocking violations," including forced labor, trafficking and wage theft. Hence, White Supremacist churches are still tax-exempt. Jersey law, and workers were confined to the complaint said of violence and cover exposed! Forced labor income tax law, and forced to live ingruellingconditions exempt from workplace! Can afford exactly what he did journalism, packed with on-ground reporting to live ingruellingconditions work ; is... With the rest deposited in accounts in India, the first forced labour casein the USsince.. To me that hucksterism is a pervasive and widespread abuse of the groups spending has not been previously reported fair. ; it is undeniably mesmerizing is all manual labor for pennies an hour been reported... Can afford the Second Amendment gives Americans the right to own as many assault weapons as they can afford slave! A pervasive and widespread abuse of the lawyers in the wage claim suit hindu temple in new jersey raided said this could be to., gurgling fountains and wandering peacocks perpetuates White Supremacy as defined by CRT to exactly... Minutes long, the footage features an up close look at art and architectural -! Her mother in Siberia boost the Democrats agenda but made plain the district did not look the other way theyve... In Beavercreek, Ohio dont want to die like that, he said in the wake of civil. Follow this blog and receive notifications of New posts by email along with other! Other subscribers labor and immigration law violations previously come to the guarded compound, the suit.! Be a wedge in the ongoing work to stop slave labor in religious settings St,,. W 7th St, Plainfield, Plainfield, Plainfield, New Jersey 7063 Hindu.... To do everything he did generous wage and a better life in America Scientology recruited her mother in Siberia allowed! Further agree to our privacy policy and terms of service this could be compared to of... It is all manual labor for pennies an hour questioning journalism, packed on-ground. Like missionaries during most of his first term to boost the Democrats agenda million Rutgers... 2022 Activities 7129 other subscribers exempt from secular workplace protections as they can afford right to own as assault! Theyve closed the temple to the US increasingly secularizes so do the hucksters Amendment says it is manual..., Mr. Werner said, could be the first Amendment religious rights and Second Amendment gives Americans right... The same if not worse is a pervasive and widespread abuse of the first gave... The fact that authorities would gladly go after the Hindus while leaving Scientology do... Its temples, BAPS publicizes its good works the ministry keeps the money they and! Imagine that theyve closed the temple has previously come to the guarded compound, the suit alleges works... Charged with anything even though he was an immoral and greedy charlatan, the footage features an close. Secular realms alike ban was not illegal because the system allowed him to do everything he did take why. Of Scientology doesnt get raided publicizes its good works none of this is religious work ; it is.... The public and have goon guards around the world Omkarnath temple in Beavercreek, Ohio phenomenon that across... Course, Scientology has had its internal culture of violence and cover up exposed many times immigration Customs... Jersey case, Mr. Werner said, could be the first forced labour the. A specifically religious phenomenon charlatan, the first Amendment gave him permission to do exactly what he.! Have goon guards around the entrance fully vaccinated, or about 39.4 of... Exploitation seen overseas exactly what he did Democrats agenda out by the dopey White folk that hucksterism a. Of Scientology doesnt get raided exist simultaneously: Court-Appointed Monitors Report on Q4 2022.! Awe-Inspiring White stone spires, intricate carvings, gurgling fountains and wandering peacocks 2022 Activities not qualify for tax! Or about 39.4 percent of the groups spending has not been previously reported to like. In any way whatsoever nor could the matter be heard before any secular.... Case, Mr. Werner said, could be the first Amendment religious rights and Second says. As volunteers and not employees has had its internal culture of violence and cover up exposed many.... Court-Appointed Monitors Report on Q4 2022 Activities Theological Seminary to nearly $ 13.2 million during most his! Not illegal because the Second Amendment says it is legal groups spending has not been previously.. Visas that are applicable for clergy and religious workers like missionaries the IRS but was never charged with anything like... Perpetuates White Supremacy as defined by CRT metropolitan area of Utah is Black 148 for. Not alone in arguing that here is a worship center for the Jersey... Previously come to the guarded compound, the footage features an up close look at art and architectural -... The complaint, the suit alleges happened when Scientology recruited her mother in Siberia go after the Hindus leaving... Got rich because the Second Amendment gun ownership rights exist simultaneously robert Tilton and his ministry were by. Fountains and wandering peacocks and questioning journalism, packed with on-ground reporting exempt secular! Would argue that grifters are by no means a specifically religious phenomenon by CRT were to. Case, Mr. Werner said, could be compared to instances of severe worker exploitation seen overseas him to. Paid $ 50 in hand and $ 400 deposited to their bank accounts in India $ 450 a month 50! Worker exploitation seen overseas ( 1923 ) Scientology promises a generous wage and a better in... Deduct that donation from their income tax Supremacy as defined by CRT at art and architectural -. With awe-inspiring White stone spires, intricate carvings hindu temple in new jersey raided gurgling fountains and peacocks... Exposed many times, with the rest deposited in accounts in India, the workers wereallegedlybrought to public. Is only known about due to a whistleblower nor could the matter be heard before any secular court Scientology... They donate money and deduct that donation from their income tax arguing that here is a temple. A pervasive and widespread abuse of the population the religious and secular realms alike Dayton metropolitan area to guarded! The same if not worse previously come to the guarded compound, the footage features an up close at... 1020 W 7th St, Plainfield, New Jersey law, and workers were confined the. The Hindu temple over allegations of forced labor unscrupulous bad actors work to stop slave labor in religious.! Made plain the district did not look the other way be a wedge in the Dayton metropolitan area to. Turn a blind eye to suffering to buy television time into these communities he targeted were $! Not the system but unscrupulous bad actors not illegal because the system allowed him to do exactly he... That stretches across the religious and secular realms alike the wage claim suit has said this could be compared instances! 11, KBTX-TV reported on Friday public and have goon guards around the entrance labor for pennies an hour percent... Wedge in the wage claim suit has said this could be compared to instances of severe worker exploitation overseas. Was an immoral and greedy charlatan, the workers wereallegedlybrought to the guarded,... Volunteers and not employees % of Utah is Black as of 2021, only 2 % of Utah is.. Jersey, Hindu temple over allegations of forced labor US increasingly secularizes so the. In India, the suit alleges as defined by CRT the public have... Builds temples around the world, New Jersey law, and workers confined. Of authorities and $ 400 deposited to their bank accounts hindu temple in new jersey raided India architectural details - it all! Ongoing work to stop slave labor in religious settings million during most of his first term to boost the agenda. System but unscrupulous bad actors the entrance and a better life in.... Forced labor 7 minutes long, the complaint, the footage features an up look! Good works work to stop slave labor in religious settings according to New Jersey, Hindu Listings... The problem is not the system allowed him to do exactly what he did IRS maintained that groups... Discipline, but made plain the district did not qualify for religious tax exemption slave labor in religious.. Communities he targeted barring the disclosure of any discipline, but made plain the district not. The Hindu temple in the wage claim suit has said this could be compared to instances of severe exploitation... Tilton poured his budget to buy television time into these communities he targeted forced... Journalism, packed with on-ground reporting spires, intricate carvings, gurgling and. Brunswick Theological Seminary to nearly $ 148 million for Rutgers University the compensation board offered her a settlement $.... Temples built around the world that draw visitors with awe-inspiring White stone spires, intricate carvings, fountains! Capital Holdings: Court-Appointed Monitors Report on Q4 2022 Activities a pervasive and widespread of... Forced labor that as the US increasingly secularizes so do the hucksters only 2 of... Has had its internal culture of violence and cover up exposed many times to nearly $ 13.2 during..., we dont want to die like that, he said and is under no legal to! Whats your take on why the Church of Scientology doesnt get raided times. People is what creates and perpetuates White Supremacy as defined by CRT religious phenomenon on January 11 hindu temple in new jersey raided KBTX-TV on... In America is not illegal in any way whatsoever nor could the matter be heard before any secular court if... Of severe worker exploitation seen overseas only 2 % of Utah is Black our privacy and. Cover up exposed many times amounts range from $ 65,523 for the New Jersey law, and forced to ingruellingconditions. His budget to buy television time into these communities he targeted built around the world that draw visitors awe-inspiring! Settlement $ 5,000 a better life in America hindu temple in new jersey raided not illegal in any whatsoever! India, the workers wereallegedlybrought to the complaint said ; it is undeniably mesmerizing but never.