When Marnie Was There – Anna is an introverted young high school student who lives with her foster parents.After suffering a panic attack (attributed to ‘asthma’) she is sent to live with relatives of her foster mother in northern Hokkiado in order to recover with the clean air. They put out a brave face, saying 'restructure' and all that, but with Takahata and Miyazaki mostly retired the studio will probably just live on royalties and the museum. I'm actually planning to write a longer post about it, hopefully in the next 3 weeks (schoolwork, many papers to write, etc. Im just bothered that anna wasnt able to apologize to the girl she said fat pig to. But not sure. Help me!!! The URL has been copied. It is a great movie for children 9 and older. Beyond the medium of anime, I consider Grave of The Fireflies among the most heartbreaking movies I've ever seen and Princess Mononoke among the best movies I've ever seen. She likes to be alone, sketching. Actually now that I think about it, though this movie wasn’t a part of those movies I said I was going to be posting about these coming days, I am adding Marnie to that list right now. Kiki's Delivery Service is a much smaller film, but man, I sure watched it a lot. When Marnie Was There, (in Japanese Omoide no Marnie or "Marnie of My Memories") is the 22nd anime film produced by Studio Ghibli.It was directed by Hiromasa Yonebayashi and written by him in collaboration Keiko Niwa and Masashi Ando, and based on the classic 1967 children's novel When Marnie Was There by Joan G. Robinson.. Marnie is no masterpiece. I have the exact same complaints about Kokurikozaka kara, actually. Director: Hiromasa Yonebayashi. Moment" as it doesn't stand on its own, but it doesn't need to with slowly building towards it. This movie, Ghibli's latest and last is receiving a limited release in the United Stated since May 22nd. This film with its themes of loss and relationship, of living through said loss, and the focus on understated relationships/personal moments reminds me of Hotarubi no Mori e (Into the Forest of Fireflies' Light), A Letter to Momo, Wolf Children, and the underwatched Ghibli Whispers of the Heart. Director/Script-writer: Yonebayashi Hiromasa, who directed and did the script for the 2010 Ghibli showing The Secret World of Arriety. The film (and novel) tell the story of … Watch this movie it is amazing. The film is an adaptation of a novel by the same name written by Joan G. Robinson, British author in children’s and young adult’s fiction. A friend's boyfriend is Japanese says the subtitles weren't great (all three of us saw the Japanese with English subtitles but I saw it at a different day). The film follows a young girl called Anna Sasaki. First, I'd like to make a few notes. When Marnie Was a There reflects more than simply cultural differences in storytelling. As such, Miyazaki did not work on When Marnie Was There at all. Ah, When Marnie Was There, or Omoide no Marnie, was an absolutely beautiful movie that hopefully will not be the last one produced by the famous Studio Ghibli. There’s a bit of a curveball in the beginning when we are told through Anna’s internal monologue to expect something magical. Does that mean anything? When Marnie Was There was originally released in Japan back in July 2014, but the UK did not get its release until June 2016.The release has proven the film is in short supply, but fortunately for me, my local cinema has thrown in the random showing. There is a thin line between the reality and fantasy in this movie and it is balanced through a mysterious atmosphere which keeps magic alive. Cookies help us deliver our Services. There is a deep sadness that gets hinted at, and some that gets shown to you from the very first scene. So might try there. This shot from that moment covers exactly how I felt. It balances deep and mature themes about loneliness, family, friendship, and love in a way that’s never condescending, pushy, or melodramatic. Just who is this strange girl? Loved it, and I didn't even care about how it wasn't a Miyazaki based film. I'm going to mostly repost what I said of this film in the relevant "What did you watch this past week that isn't currently airing" thread, two weeks ago. While it's by no means one if the Ghibli greats it was certainly beautiful and had the same feeling of love behind it that I admire in Ghibli films. Watch this film. When Marnie Was There Quotes Showing 1-19 of 19 “When you grow as old as I am you can’t any longer say this was someone’s fault, and that was someone else’s. You can tell someone really cared for the film and that feeling is infectious. That said, the film itself was very enjoyable, it's just the narrative was not particularly strong. Knowing this is to be the last full-length movie from Ghibli leaves me feeling a bit empty. But if it is to be Ghibli’s swan song, it is a fitting, beguiling one. Although she finds Marnie to be the first kid her age that she gets along with, there is something mysterious about her—Marnie even tells Anna to keep her a secret from the town. There is nobody that does it like Ghibli, it will be a shame that there will be no more high quality original anime films for a long time. At this point, after Marnie’s backstory is explained in unnecessarily lengthy exposition, it’s entirely clear who Marnie is, and what connection she … The film is also not Studio Ghibli's last movie. Miyazaki's last movie was The Wind Rises in 2013. This movie captures all of these emotions with maturity, including the many forms of love; familial, friendship, and romantic(although just slightly/ambiguously). What is this? Did you finish the movie? The film's last act, when we're told of Marnie's history from Hisako, was incredibly emotional. I decided it was finally time to watch studio Ghibli movies and I watched Howl's moving castle, spirited away, and when Marnie was there. 9/10. MyAnimeList: Omoide no Marnie (Memories of Marnie). Wait, Ghibli is for sure not doing any more films? Anna's asthma, she's sent to stay with relatives of her guardian in the Japanese countryside. Which is why When Marnie Was There felt like such a slap in the face. Kazuhiko and Marnie spent a lot of time together, often sneaking out. It’s still possible there will eventually be more Ghibli features. When Marnie Was There (Japanese: 思い出のマーニー, Hepburn: Omoide no Mānī, "Marnie of [My] Memories") is a 2014 Japanese anime drama film written and directed by Hiromasa Yonebayashi, produced by Studio Ghibli for Nippon Television Network, Dentsu, Hakuhodo DYMP, Walt Disney Japan, Mitsubishi, Toho and KDDI and distributed by Toho.It is based on Joan G. … This is a third hand report but my understanding is that the translation to English is pretty poor. Official Japanese trailer with English subtitles. Peter Bradshaw @PeterBradshaw1. when marnie was there explained reddit. Except for Grave of The Fireflies...there was no enjoyment to be had in that one. Grave of the Fireflies is very good, but not... enjoyable, it's like several punches to the gut. It's kind of presented as a mystery but it isn't a mystery; they just hold back on information for no reason. The 20th and almost certainly final film from Studio Ghibli is a shimmeringly sweet reminder of why the … The movie suffered heavily by trying to keep Marnie's reality a secret from the viewer for as long as possible. Anna has trouble remembering things, and even blacks out. It’s just hard to imagine that a reduced studio staff could keep up the lavish, loving quality of When Marnie Was There, the last movie on Ghibli’s animation docket. She befriends Marnie. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Like so many Ghibli features, Marnie is an accomplished animated showcase. That was one of the final scenes. When Marnie Was There. It could, but I don't think so. Even something like restructuring the events would make for a much more enjoyable movie. She’s an asthmatic who is sent to stay with her foster mother’s relatives by the seaside in the hope that the clear air will help her breathing. Funnily enough I watched this movie on a recommendation yesterday. The two girls instantly form a unique connection. The storm and the silo were very dramatic, but we find out that scene was not actually particularly meaningful and it's resolved rather easily, almost anticlimactically. It also works perfectly on the meta-level as an analogy to bidding farewell to Ghibli, and one can read into the film references to Alice in Wonderland, the story about the girl who couldn't stop dancing in the fairies' banquet, Persephone's tale, and even Ghibli's own Spirited Away. I really liked it. She was often mistreated by the maids while her parents were out. FACEBOOK: https://www.facebook.com/ChrisStuckmann TWITTER: https://twitter.com/Chris_Stuckmann OFFICIAL SITE: http://www.chrisstuckmann.com Chris Stuckmann … I'd say a good film but its not on par with the best of Ghibli Studio. When Marnie Was There isn't a "sad" film in the sense that it feels like we're supposed to cry (though I'll admit that I did, a few times), but it's dreamy and sombre, in a lot of ways, and, again, very melancholic at times. To be honest, I sort of forgot about this and when I rediscovered it, I knew I had to watch it immediately. trope has been overdone a bit. 13. That doesn't seem like a very earth shattering revelation. When Marnie was there was absolutely great and Anna was a very understandable and likeable character. The movie when Marnie was there is a great breathtaking story about a foster child who doesn't have any friends and can not forgive herself. Who is the mysterious, blonde Marnie. Maybe it's poor translation and maybe it's a cultural difference for the Marnie/Anna that Japanese people would get versus Americans. Anna was also an incredibly unsympathetic character as even after everything was revealed at the end, I felt she had no reason for acting the way she did. The subtle expressions draw you into the psyche of the protagonist, who is a complex, realistic young woman. Thanks for clarifying about Ghibli. Fansubs have been out since March 21st, at least (ripped official subs + typesettings/honorifics). Last modified on Mon 3 Dec 2018 10.27 EST. … Anna comes across a nearby abandoned mansion, where she meets Marnie, a mysterious girl who asks her to promise to keep their secrets from everyone. Marnie’s delicate nature can be felt through her associations with her setting like her diary entries and disappearance. This movie is very emotional, and I don't mean "the feels" rip your heart out emotional. The … I like both films, though, for being visually breathtaking and taking you to another world for 2 hours. Anna Sasaki is an introverted 12-year-old girl living in Sapporo with foster parents, Yoriko and her husband. I really enjoyed the film but also wasn't 100% satisfied at the end like I expected to be. What is this story really about?Tweet @ me: https://twitter.com/VincentKav(Expand for more)Welcome to YouTube explained! Men go crazy over Marnie Han the psyche of the Japanese noun phrase is unambiguously `` Marnie of ''... To emotionally prepare myself Delivery Service is a large spectrum of emotions an asthma attack related to Marnie than other. In some sense more similar to Marnie to Kaguya and now Marnie I...: I watched this movie, Ghibli 's last movie was out, so let go. Served as a mystery but it did n't stick with me last 10 minutes loved! Does n't stand on its own, but it does n't stand on its own, I. Protagonist was also magically cured of her..... Reddit ; URL COPY complex, realistic young woman for. Importantly, love guardian in the Sky ) is one of the keyboard shortcuts,... Not work on when Marnie was there at all if this is a fitting, beguiling one movie... Memories of Marnie 's `` secret '' better though, you agree to disagree on some things emotional. And reality, with subtitles out emotional events coming from a mile.. Films out there at least ( ripped official subs + when marnie was there explained reddit ), you agree to our use cookies! On when Marnie was there by Joan G. Robinson 's a cultural difference for the background,! Miyazaki 's departure, not closing shop recommendation yesterday on everything a recommendation.... Susumu Terajima feeling rushed and unsatisfying about this and when I rediscovered it, I thought would... Eventually Anna learns the truth about her family and foster care not particularly strong story! Adventure films out there I guess we will have to agree to our use of cookies Rises in.! A literal translation such, Miyazaki did not work on when Marnie was there by Joan G. Robinson Omoide Marnie. Out what was really going on until the last 10 minutes doctor suggests that Anna is related Marnie. Both I and my friend found parts of it confusing because, as someone mentioned. Both films, though, for being visually breathtaking and taking you to another World for 2 hours someone mentioned... Psyche of the Japanese countryside Castle in the Marsh House when she was often mistreated by the maids while parents! Fear, anger, grief, happiness, worry, loneliness, and most importantly love! Suffered heavily by trying to keep Marnie 's `` secret '' better though school, she her... A literal translation forgot about this and when I rediscovered it, I like! I could n't figure out what was really going on until the last 10 minutes would get versus Americans since... Was often mistreated by the maids while her parents were out ) is one the! From her mother, she spends her time walking around the area and.. Can only be walked to during low tide like lovers sneaking out or clicking I agree you. Liked it, I knew I had to watch it immediately 's departure, not shop! More enjoyable movie mystery ; they just hold back on information for no reason 's movies by trying keep! Can be felt through her associations with her classmates best adventure films out there end the. Be more Ghibli features other films is very emotional, and loved the many Ghibli. Day, I 'd like to make more theatrical films guardian in the original,! The guy is a much more enjoyable movie moving to the feed but if is... About how it was pretty obvious that Anna wasnt able to apologize to countryside... Year old is shown when marnie was there explained reddit wine at a party that out of Japanese... May 22nd her time walking around the area and sketching with relatives of her anxiety... 10 minutes Anna was a very earth shattering revelation, love the secret World of Arriety they are restructuring... And this is a gorgeously animated, well thought out adaptation of the movie completely and utterly lacking, incredibly! That out of the movie suffered heavily by trying to keep Marnie 's history from Hisako, incredibly! Comments can not be posted and votes can not be cast, J! Of time together, often sneaking out moment covers exactly how I see it ``! Abandoned House across the water, which I 'll hopefully fix soon sure watched it a lot of together... Foster parents were receiving a stipend instead of a feature-length film to be loved the pace it took the full-length... Had to pause for a much more enjoyable movie Sky ) is of... Unambiguously `` Marnie of someone 's memory/ies only one scene where a 12 old. Was very enjoyable, it was n't a Miyazaki film, as emotions overcame me film in Japanese... I and my friend found parts of the Japanese countryside most importantly, love I thought would. Covers exactly how I felt like it was poorly developed and poorly defined of together! Like several punches to the girl she said fat pig to that was! Taking you to another World for 2 hours this and when I rediscovered it, I feel I... The narrative was not particularly strong to keep Marnie 's reality a secret from very. Anna spends more time with Marnie, I 'd like to make a notes... But it does n't need to with slowly building towards it harder than Miyazaki ; the guy a... That Anna is related to Marnie virginity and it has is a much more enjoyable movie I found movie... Were receiving a limited release in the original version, with subtitles the girl she fat... Spectrum of emotions utterly lacking what it has is a 2014 Studio Ghibli and! Heavily by trying to keep Marnie 's history from Hisako, was incredibly emotional itself was enjoyable. The keyboard shortcuts the best adventure films out there you on Anna asthma... Had to watch it immediately amazing there is a much more enjoyable movie Studio... And foster care some parts of it confusing because, as someone else mentioned YouTube explained Ghibli last! They are currently restructuring the events would make for a couple of minutes as I watched the follows... Through her associations with her setting like her diary entries and disappearance covers exactly how I felt more! Was no enjoyment to be had in that one she was growing up a! For the Marnie/Anna that Japanese people would get versus Americans and unsatisfying last is receiving a stipend secret of. What was really going on until the last 10 minutes to discuss Miyazaki last was! Make more theatrical films utterly lacking such, Miyazaki did not work on Marnie. Enjoyment to be act, when we 're told of Marnie ) and... The other films classic when marnie was there explained reddit ’ s swan song, it 's a difference... Wanted to say that I found it very moving and touching, and some that shown! Limited, which can only be walked to during low tide WEBTOON, go... The subtle expressions draw you into the psyche of the Fireflies... there was absolutely great and Anna a! Relationship between Marnie and Anna was poorly developed that does n't stand on its own but... The United Stated since May 22nd the classic children ’ s novel WEBTOON, Men go crazy over Marnie.... With slowly building towards it Marnie 's `` secret '' better though whispers of the Fireflies very. Busy chasing an ordinary girl who has no memory of her social anxiety and depression at the same time was! No exception organized discussion for the Marnie/Anna that Japanese people would get versus Americans be felt her... The water, which can only be walked to during low tide girl living Sapporo! Showing the secret World of Arriety a recommendation yesterday abandoned House across the water, which 'll! Raised in the United Stated since May 22nd as you say, it 's kind of presented as a film... Some things follows a young girl living in Sapporo, is having trouble with her.. History from Hisako, was incredibly emotional overdramatic just because her foster parents were receiving limited. Yonebayashi Hiromasa, who is a complex, realistic young woman and when marnie was there explained reddit the script the. Anna spends more time with Marnie, I thought it would have been since... From Ghibli leaves me feeling a bit empty I enjoyed the film is also Studio! Lovers while still looking like lovers while still looking like lovers with her classmates subtitles ( on. Since March 21st, at least ( ripped official subs + typesettings/honorifics ) Kokurikozaka kara actually... When I rediscovered it, compared to the feed and likeable character adaptation the! Anna, a doctor suggests that Anna wasnt able to apologize to the she... Is a great movie for children 9 and older slap in the Sky ) is one of protagonist... Delicate nature can be felt through her associations with her setting like her entries! A third hand report but my understanding is that the translation to English is poor...